
Price an accounting proposal as three fixed-fee options built from a written scope, not as an hourly estimate. For 2025, the most common fees reported by US firms in Ignition’s 2025 Accounting and Tax Pricing Benchmark were $400 to $599 per individual return, $1,000 to $1,499 per business return, $250 to $499 a month for bookkeeping, and more than $2,500 a month for CFO and controller work. Below is a copy-ready proposal template with a 3-tier pricing table, the math behind each tier, the software that sends it (with verified USD prices), and the AICPA and Circular 230 fee rules your proposal has to respect.
Want an outside expert to find your biggest growth lever? See how CO Consulting’s growth consulting works.
Accounting proposal pricing benchmarks: what US firms charge in 2025
Two public sources give real fee data for small and midsize US firms. Neither is a perfect sample, so use them as a sanity check on your own numbers, not as a price list.
| Service | Most common fee reported | Share of firms in that band | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Individual tax return | $400 to $599 per return | 27% | Ignition 2025 benchmark |
| Business tax return | $1,000 to $1,499 per year | 29% | Ignition 2025 benchmark |
| Tax planning and advisory | More than $2,000 per year | 25% | Ignition 2025 benchmark |
| Monthly bookkeeping and accounting | $250 to $499 per month | 29% | Ignition 2025 benchmark |
| CFO and controller services | More than $2,500 per month | 23% | Ignition 2025 benchmark |
| Form 1040, itemized | $300 to $600 average fee | n/a | NSA 2024 Income and Fees Survey |
| Form 1120 | $750 to $1,250 average fee | n/a | NSA 2024 Income and Fees Survey |
| Surcharge for disorganized or incomplete files | $100 to $200 average | 67% of firms charge it | NSA 2024 Income and Fees Survey |
How to read these numbers:
- Ignition’s sample is its own customers. The benchmark surveyed 219 US accounting firms that use Ignition, as CPA Practice Advisor reported. Firms that already use proposal software tend to be further along on fixed pricing. The same survey found only 3% bill tax prep hourly, 17% bill tax planning hourly, and hourly CFO billing fell to 10%.
- NSA skews toward small, independent practices. The NSA 2024 Profit and Practice Report summary covers 183 participants, 68% of them with one full-time principal and 51% Enrolled Agents. It found 37% use fixed fees for tax prep and 24% combine fixed and hourly. It also found 61% raise tax prep fees every year, and 38% to 39% charge separately for extensions or expedited returns.
- Fees are moving up. In the Ignition survey, 80% of firms planned 2026 increases averaging 5% to 10%. The AICPA’s 2025 PCPS/CPA.com MAP Survey (1,073 completed responses) reported a median 6.7% rise in net client fees and a decline in hourly billing. The detailed MAP fee tables are for AICPA members only.
The practical takeaway: if your compliance-only price sits well below these bands, the problem is rarely the proposal. It is the price.
Copy-ready accounting proposal template with a 3-tier pricing table
Paste this into your proposal tool or a Word document. Replace everything in [brackets]. The worked example uses a hypothetical client: a dental practice organized as an S corporation, 14 staff, about $2.4M in revenue, whose owner wants a bank line of credit to open a second location.
Section 1. Where you are today
[Client name], thank you for walking me through the practice on [date]. Here is what I heard: your books are usually closed six to eight weeks after month end, you paid an estimated-tax underpayment penalty last year, you spend about [10] hours a month answering finance questions yourself, and your bank wants two years of accrual financials plus a forecast before it will approve a [$400,000] line of credit for the second location. You want to make that decision by [month].
Section 2. What changes when we work together
Books closed by the 10th of every month. A tax projection updated each quarter so estimated payments match what you will actually owe. A lender-ready financial package by [date]. One person at our firm who knows your numbers and answers within one business day.
Section 3. Your three options
| Compliance | Advisory (recommended) | CFO | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Accurate books and on-time filings | Planning taxes before year end, not after | Funding and running the second location with a finance lead |
| Monthly bookkeeping and bank, card and loan reconciliations | Included | Included | Included |
| Form 1120-S and owner’s Form 1040 (federal and one state) | Included | Included | Included |
| Quarterly estimated tax calculations | Included | Included | Included |
| Month-end close by the 10th, with a one-page KPI report | Included | Included | |
| Quarterly tax planning meeting with a written projection | Included | Included | |
| Annual reasonable-compensation review for the owner’s S corp salary | Included | Included | |
| 13-week cash flow forecast, updated weekly | Included | ||
| Annual budget and second-location model | Included | ||
| Monthly CFO meeting and lender package | Included | ||
| Fixed monthly fee | $675 | $1,350 | $3,300 |
| Annual equivalent | $8,100 | $16,200 | $39,600 |
Section 4. What is not included
Payroll processing, sales tax filings, IRS or state examination representation, prior-year cleanup, returns for additional entities or family members, and financial statement audits or reviews. We will quote any of these separately, in writing, before starting.
Section 5. How we will work
Week 1: secure portal set up and bank feeds connected. Week 2: kickoff call and document checklist. Month 1: first close and baseline report. Communication through the portal; replies within one business day.
Section 6. Fees and terms
Fees are billed on the 1st of each month by automatic ACH or card. The fee covers the scope above for 12 months. Work outside scope is quoted as a fixed fee before we begin. Fees are reviewed each [January] with 60 days’ written notice of any change.
Section 7. Next step
Choose an option and sign below by [date, 10 business days out] so we can complete onboarding before [deadline]. If you would like to change anything in the scope, reply and I will revise it the same day.
The order matters. The client reads their own situation and outcomes before they see a number, and the exclusions sit right after the price so nobody is surprised in month three. If you want the psychology behind three options in more depth, the good, better, best pricing guide covers tier design for service firms in general.
How to price each tier: cost floor, market check, value ceiling
Every tier price in the example above came from three tests. Run them in this order for every proposal.
Test 1. The cost floor
Estimate annual hours per tier, multiply by your fully loaded cost per hour (salary, payroll taxes, benefits, software and overhead divided by billable hours), then divide by (1 minus your target margin). The example assumes a $60 loaded cost per hour and a 45% target margin. Both are assumptions: calculate your own.
| Tier | Hours per year | Cost at $60/hour | Floor at 45% margin | Floor per month | Proposed price | Resulting margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Compliance | 65 (48 bookkeeping, 10 for the 1120-S, 5 for the 1040, 2 for estimates) | $3,900 | $7,091 | $591 | $675/month | 51.9% |
| Advisory | 121 (adds 24 close review, 16 planning meetings, 4 comp review, 12 KPI reports) | $7,260 | $13,200 | $1,100 | $1,350/month | 55.2% |
| CFO | 229 (adds 52 cash forecast, 12 budget, 36 CFO meetings, 8 lender package) | $13,740 | $24,982 | $2,082 | $3,300/month | 65.3% |
Formula for the floor: hours x loaded cost per hour / (1 minus target margin). Compliance: 65 x $60 = $3,900, and $3,900 / 0.55 = $7,091 a year. Never send a tier priced below its floor. If a prospect needs it cheaper, take scope out.
Test 2. The market check
Compare the compliance tier against the benchmark bands. At the top of Ignition’s most common ranges, the parts add up to $499 x 12 for bookkeeping, plus $1,499 for the business return, plus $599 for the individual return, which is $8,086 a year. The proposed $8,100 sits right at that line, which is reasonable for a 14-person practice with payroll accounts, a practice loan and multiple card feeds. The CFO tier at $3,300 a month sits inside the “more than $2,500” band that 23% of surveyed firms reported. Compliance is the tier prospects can comparison-shop, so it is the one that has to survive this check.
Test 3. The value ceiling (worked example)
Value pricing means the price is set by what the outcome is worth to this client, measured in the client’s own numbers from the discovery call. In the example, the owner said:
- She spends about 10 hours a month on finance questions, and values her time at $250 an hour: 10 x 12 x $250 = $30,000 a year.
- She paid a $2,400 underpayment penalty last year, which quarterly projections are designed to prevent: $2,400.
- Her alternative to the CFO tier was hiring a part-time controller at $45 an hour for 20 hours a week: 45 x 20 x 52 = $46,800 a year before payroll taxes and benefits.
Advisory value: $30,000 + $2,400 = $32,400. CFO value: $32,400 + $46,800 = $79,200. My own rule of thumb, not an industry standard, is to keep each price at or below half of the first-year value the client named, so the return reads as at least 2 to 1 in their numbers. Half of $32,400 is $16,200, which is exactly the Advisory price ($1,350 x 12). Half of $79,200 is $39,600, which is exactly the CFO price ($3,300 x 12). Both clear their cost floors with room to spare, which is the point: value pricing lifts margin on advisory work, while compliance stays near market.
If the value ceiling comes in below the cost floor, do not offer that tier to this client. That is a qualification signal, not a pricing problem. Your discovery call questions are where these numbers come from, so ask for them in dollars and hours, not adjectives.
Pricing for accounting proposals: scope lines and add-on fees to spell out
Most fixed-fee losses come from scope that was never written down. Put these lines in every proposal, priced or explicitly excluded.
| Scope item | Write it as | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Transaction volume | “Up to [300] transactions and [4] bank or card accounts per month” | Gives you a written trigger to re-price when the client opens location two |
| Late or incomplete documents | “Documents received after [March 1] or incomplete files: $[150] processing fee” | 67% of NSA respondents charge this, averaging $100 to $200 |
| Extensions and rush work | “Extension filing included” or “$[X] per extension”; “Rush turnaround under 5 business days: $[X]” | 38% and 39% of NSA respondents charge separately for these |
| Prior-year cleanup | Separate one-time fixed fee, quoted after a books review | Keeps catch-up work out of your monthly margin |
| IRS or state notices | “Responses to routine notices included; examinations quoted separately” | Examination work is also where contingent fees may be allowed (see the rules below) |
| Additional entities and family returns | “$[X] per additional return” | Stops the “can you just do my son’s return” creep |
Proposal software for accountants: verified USD prices
All prices below were checked on each vendor’s own US pricing page or pricing feed. “Annual” means the monthly rate when billed yearly.
| Tool | Plans and USD prices | Proposal-relevant limits | Payment fees (US) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ignition (formerly Practice Ignition) | Solo $39/month annual or $49 monthly; Core $99 annual or $149 monthly; Pro $229 annual or $279 monthly; Pro+ $399 annual or $499 monthly; Enterprise custom | Active clients included: 20 / 50 / 350 / 600, then $7 / $5 / $3 / $2 per extra client. Users: 1 / 3 / 15 / 20. Up to 3 options per proposal on every plan. Solo is for firms under $150k revenue | Card 2.5% + $0.30; ACH 1% + $0.30, capped at $5 (Core plan figures) |
| Karbon | Team $59 per user/month annual or $79 monthly; Business $89 annual or $99 monthly; Enterprise custom. Monthly billing only for teams of 4+ | Engagements (proposals and engagement letters) listed on Team and up; proposals and letters do not use eSignature credits | Standard cards 2.6% + $0.30; ACH 1% + $0.30, max $5 |
| Canopy | Standard $74 per user/month; Plus $109; Premium $149 (all billed annually) | Engagement Builder with price book, packages, add-ons and e-signature | Cards 3.30% + $0.20; ACH 1%, capped at $10 |
| TaxDome | Essentials $800 per seat/year (1-year term), $750 (2-year), $700 (3-year); Pro $1,000 / $950 / $900; Business $1,200 / $1,150 / $1,100 | Proposals and payment collection included from Essentials, which is for solo users only | Not compared here |
| Anchor | $0 subscription; Anchor deducts $5 from each payment you receive | Unlimited users, clients, proposals and agreements | ACH free; card 2.9% + $0.30, paid by the client |
How to choose: if proposals are the only problem, Ignition or Anchor solve it without changing your practice management system. Ignition’s Core plan is the cheapest tier that renders a 3-option proposal for a 3-person firm with up to 50 signed clients. If you also need workflow and a client portal, Karbon, Canopy and TaxDome bundle proposals with the rest, and per-seat pricing matters more than proposal features. Whatever you pick, turn on payment capture at signing so the ACH authorization is collected in the same step as the signature.
How to present price in the meeting: order, anchoring, and the words to use
Present the proposal live on a call or screen share. Do not email a PDF and wait. Here is the sequence I use, in order:
- Replay their situation (2 minutes). Read Section 1 aloud and ask, “Did I get anything wrong?” Corrections here are cheap. Corrections after the price are objections.
- Confirm the number they care about. “You said the line of credit decision has to happen by [month]. Is that still the deadline?”
- Show the CFO tier first. Walk the table from right to left. The highest tier sets the reference point, so the recommended tier reads as the sensible middle rather than the expensive option.
- Recommend one tier and say why in their terms. “Based on what you told me, I would start with Advisory. It covers the penalty problem and gives the bank the financials it asked for. If you decide to open the second location, we move you to CFO.”
- Say the price once, then stop talking. “That is $1,350 a month, fixed, for everything in that column.” Do not justify it before they react.
- Answer the question behind the objection. “Too high” usually means “too high for what I think I am getting.” Move scope, not price: offer Compliance, or remove a line item. Never discount the same scope in the meeting. The objection handling scripts for accountants have word-for-word replies.
- Ask for the decision and sign in the meeting. “Would you like me to send the Advisory option for signature now? It takes about two minutes and sets up the monthly ACH.”
Three rules for the pricing table itself: show monthly fees, not hourly rates or hour estimates; keep the gap between tiers wide enough that each one is a visibly different service (the example roughly doubles each step); and list exclusions directly under the table. If they still go quiet, use the proposal follow-up email templates on day 1, 3, 7, 12 and 21.
Engagement letter, independence and fee rules your proposal must respect
Your proposal becomes your engagement letter, so the fee language is regulated. These are the rules that most often affect accounting proposal pricing. Check them against the current AICPA Code of Professional Conduct (the copy linked is updated through December 2023) and your state board’s rules, which can be stricter. This is not legal advice.
| Rule | What it says | What it means for your proposal |
|---|---|---|
| AICPA Contingent Fees Rule, 1.510.001 | No contingent fee from a client for whom you perform an audit, review, a compilation a third party may use (unless independence is disclosed), or an examination of prospective financial information. No contingent fee for preparing an original or amended return or refund claim, for any client | Do not price tax prep as “a percentage of the refund” or “free if we do not save you money.” Fees may vary with complexity (1.510.001.04) |
| Permitted contingent fees, 1.510.010 | Examples include representing a client in a revenue agent’s examination, and refund claims based on a test-case issue or above the Joint Committee review threshold. Not permitted: an amended return for a deduction you simply missed | Price exam representation separately from the compliance tiers |
| Commissions and Referral Fees Rule, 1.520.001 | No commissions from attest clients; permitted commissions and any referral fees must be disclosed | If the CFO tier recommends software, insurance or financing that pays you, disclose it in writing |
| Unpaid fees, 1.230.010 | Unpaid fees for an attest client are acceptable if clearly insignificant and for services less than one year before the current attest report; significant fees older than one year impair independence | Use automatic ACH billing for attest clients so receivables never age past a year |
| Determining attest fees, 1.230.030 (effective January 1, 2025) | Other services you provide may not influence the attest fee, except for cost savings from experience gained doing them | Do not bundle a discounted audit or review into an advisory package |
| Nonattest services, 1.295.030 and 1.295.040 | Assuming management responsibilities for an attest client impairs independence; nonattest services need a client-designated overseer and a written understanding of objectives, services, responsibilities and limitations | A CFO tier that sets strategy or authorizes transactions cannot be sold to a client you audit or review |
| Advertising and Solicitation Rule, 1.600.001 | No false, misleading or deceptive advertising or solicitation | No promised tax savings or guaranteed outcomes in the proposal copy |
| IRS Circular 230, 31 CFR 10.27 | No unconscionable fees; contingent fees generally barred for matters before the IRS, with exceptions for examinations, interest and penalty refund claims, and judicial proceedings | In Ridgely v. Lew (D.D.C. 2014) the court barred the IRS from enforcing 10.27 for ordinary refund claims. Treasury proposed replacing 10.27 in December 2024; the CPA Journal describes it as still a proposal. The AICPA rule above still applies to CPA members either way |
Fee clauses to paste into the engagement letter
- Scope: “Our fixed fee covers only the services listed in the option you selected. Any other service will be quoted in writing, as a fixed fee, before work begins.”
- Volume trigger: “If monthly transactions exceed [300] or accounts exceed [4] for two consecutive months, we will propose a revised fee, effective after 30 days’ notice.”
- Annual review: “Fees are reviewed each [January]. We will give at least 60 days’ written notice of any change.” When that date comes, the price increase letter templates for accountants give you the wording.
- Payment: “Fees are charged on the 1st of each month to the payment method authorized at signing. If a payment fails and is not resolved within 15 days, we may pause work until the account is current.”
- Termination: “Either party may end this agreement with 30 days’ written notice. Fees for work completed through the termination date remain due.”
Once the proposal is signed, the first 30 days decide whether the client renews at next year’s price. Hand it straight to your client onboarding checklist. And if your pricing problem is really a positioning problem (prospects keep comparing you to the cheapest preparer in town), that is worth fixing upstream; you can book a consultation to work through it.
Work with CO Consulting
Find and fix your biggest growth constraint
- Built for service businesses doing $1M to $25M in revenue
- A diagnostic that maps your funnel, unit economics, channels and team
- A 90-day execution plan with clear KPIs, done-for-you or transfer-of-knowledge
- No guaranteed lead or revenue figures; any consultant who promises them is guessing
Book a free strategy callHow we work with CPA and accounting firms
Frequently asked questions
What should pricing for an accounting proposal look like?
Show three fixed monthly fees tied to a written scope, such as Compliance, Advisory and CFO, with the recommended option in the middle and exclusions listed directly under the table. Avoid hourly rates and hour estimates. Each tier should clear your cost floor (hours times loaded cost, divided by one minus target margin) and sit below the value the client named on the discovery call.
What is the average accounting proposal price for monthly bookkeeping?
In Ignition's 2025 benchmark of 219 US firms using its software, the most common monthly bookkeeping and accounting fee was $250 to $499 a month, reported by 29% of firms. CFO and controller services most often ran above $2,500 a month (23% of firms). Price higher when transaction volume, payroll accounts or multiple entities add hours.
How much do accountants charge for tax returns in a proposal?
Ignition's 2025 survey found the most common fees were $400 to $599 per individual return and $1,000 to $1,499 per business return. The NSA 2024 Income and Fees Survey of 183 mostly small practices reported average fees of $300 to $600 for an itemized Form 1040 and $750 to $1,250 for a Form 1120.
Should accounting proposal pricing be fixed fee or hourly?
Fixed fee for nearly everything. In Ignition's 2025 data only 3% of firms billed tax prep hourly and hourly CFO billing fell to 10%. The NSA found 37% of small practices use fixed fees for tax prep and 24% mix fixed and hourly. Fixed fees work when scope, volume limits and out-of-scope pricing are written into the proposal.
Can a CPA put a contingent fee in an accounting proposal?
Not for preparing an original or amended return or refund claim, under AICPA rule 1.510.001, and never for an audit, review or similar attest client. Permitted examples in 1.510.010 include representation in an IRS examination. Circular 230 section 10.27 also restricts contingent fees, though Ridgely v. Lew (2014) blocked enforcement for ordinary refund claims. Check your state board.
What software do accountants use for proposal pricing?
Common choices are Ignition (Core $99 a month billed annually, up to 3 options per proposal), Anchor ($0 subscription, $5 per payment received), Karbon (Team $59 per user a month annually), Canopy (Standard $74 per user a month) and TaxDome (Essentials $800 per seat a year). Pick standalone proposal tools if your workflow system already works.
How much should accounting firms raise proposal prices each year?
In Ignition's 2025 benchmark, 80% of firms planned 2026 increases averaging 5% to 10%. The NSA 2024 survey found 61% of small practices raise tax prep fees every year, and the AICPA's 2025 MAP survey reported a median 6.7% rise in net client fees. Put an annual fee review clause with 60 days' notice in every engagement letter.
More marketing guides for cpa
- Brand Messaging and Positioning for CPA and Accounting Firms
- Marketing Automation for CPA and Accounting Firms Without Losing the Personal Touch
- Networking and Events That Build a Referral Pipeline for Your Accounting Firm
- How Accounting Firms Earn PR and Media Coverage That Builds Authority
- Marketing for CPA & Accounting Firms
About the author
Christoph Olivier Christoph Olivier is the founder of CO Consulting and a fractional CMO who has managed millions of dollars in ad spend and built a combined audience of over a million followers across social platforms.