
A re-engagement gift card email for a tax firm works best as one short, personal note with one small offer: for example, a $25 e-gift card for a 20-minute planning review, a booking deadline, and a footer that says plainly that the email is an advertisement and can be stopped with one click. Below you get two gift card versions ready to copy, a 3-email sequence with send days, a version with no incentive, a sunset email and the KPIs to track.
Before you send, a tax firm has more rules to clear than a retailer does. These are the $25 business gift deduction cap under IRC 274(b), AICPA independence rules if the recipient is an attest client, IRC 7216 limits on using your client list, Circular 230, CAN-SPAM, the federal gift card rules and the Gmail and Yahoo sender limits. Each rule is covered after the templates and linked to its primary source. This is a reading of rule text, not legal or tax advice.
Re-engagement gift card email template: two versions to copy
Choose a version by asking one question: does the card depend on the person doing something? A card sent with no strings is a business gift. A card sent only after someone books and attends a review is a reward for an action, and the tax treatment can differ, as the 274(b) section explains. Fill in everything in brackets with real details.
Version A: $25 gift card for a 20-minute planning review (conditional)
Send to: former clients with no engagement, invoice or reply in 12 or more months, and prospects who opted in to your emails. Do not send to audit, review or compilation clients.
Subject: A $25 thank-you for 20 minutes of your time
Alternates: “[First name], 20 minutes before December 31?” or “Your 2026 tax picture, plus a $25 gift card”
Preview text: Book a short review by [date]. We email the card after the call.
Hi [First name],
It has been a while since we worked on your [2024] return. Some rules changed for 2026, including [one real change that applies to this segment, stated exactly as the IRS states it], and it is worth checking whether it touches your situation.
I would like to spend 20 minutes on a call reviewing where you stand before year end. You do not need to prepare anything, and there is no obligation to hire us for anything.
As a thank-you for your time, we will email you a $25 [retailer, or “choose-your-own”] e-gift card within [3] business days after the call.
Book a time by [date]: [booking link]
[Your name], [CPA / EA]
[Firm name] | [phone]
Offer terms (paste under the signature): “One $25 e-gift card per person, sent after a completed review call booked by [date]. Not available to the firm’s audit, review or compilation clients or their officers. The review is general and educational; any engagement is agreed separately in writing. The card is issued by [issuer] and subject to its terms.”
Footer (every version): “This email is an advertisement from [Firm name], [street address or registered PO box]. You are receiving it because you were a client of the firm in [year]. Unsubscribe with one click: [link].”
Version B: no-strings thank-you gift card (unconditional)
Send to: former clients you want to thank, with nothing asked in return. Skip anyone you have already given a business gift this tax year (the reason is in the 274(b) section).
Subject: A small thank-you from [Firm name]
Preview text: Nothing to book and nothing to sign.
Hi [First name],
You trusted us with your [year] return, and we never properly thanked you for it. Here is a $25 [retailer] e-gift card: [claim link].
There is nothing to book. If something has changed since we last spoke, such as a new business, a home sale or a retirement date, reply to this email and I will tell you honestly whether it is worth a conversation.
[Your name]
[Firm name]
Which version to send to whom
| Recipient | Send | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Lapsed 1040 client, not an attest client | Version A or B | No independence issue; check the 7216 list rules if the offer is planning, not return prep |
| Audit, review or compilation client, or an officer or significant owner of one | No-incentive version | AICPA 1.285.010 treats gifts to attest clients as an independence question |
| Client who already got a business gift from you this tax year | Version A or no incentive | A second gift adds no deduction once the person is at $25 |
| Opted-in prospect who never signed | Version A, prospect wording | Circular 230 wants the solicitation identified and the source of their details named |
| Your firm is licensed in California | No-incentive version until the Board answers | B&P Code 5061 bars paying “other consideration” to obtain a client |
| Contact on your client list with no 7216 consent, offer is a paid planning engagement | Get consent first, or offer return preparation | The 7216 client-list exception covers return prep solicitations only |
The rules a tax firm has to clear before offering a gift card
| Rule | What it says | What it changes in your email |
|---|---|---|
| IRC 274(b) | Business gift deduction capped at $25 per recipient per tax year | Budget the card at $25; a conditional card may not be a “gift” at all |
| AICPA 1.285.010 | Unreasonable gifts to attest clients impair independence | Suppress attest clients from gift card sends |
| IRC 7216 and Treas. Reg. 301.7216-2(n) | Your client list is tax return information; it can be used to solicit return prep only | Planning offers need a signed consent first |
| Circular 230, 31 CFR 10.30 | No misleading claims; identify solicitations; keep copies | No savings promises; add a “why you got this” line; archive the send for 36 months |
| CAN-SPAM | Ad disclosure, postal address, working opt-out | Footer on every email; honor opt-outs within 10 business days |
| Regulation E, 12 CFR 1005.20 | Gift card funds last at least 5 years; dormancy fees limited | Mostly the issuer’s job; matters if you issue your own certificates |
The $25 business gift limit, and why a conditional card may not be a gift
Under IRC section 274(b)(1), no deduction is allowed for business gifts to any individual to the extent they exceed $25 for the same taxable year. IRS Publication 463 (2025) adds the details that matter for a firm:
- Partners count as one giver. “If a partnership gives gifts, the partnership and the partners are treated as one taxpayer.” Two partners each sending the same former client a $25 card still get one $25 deduction.
- Spouses count as one. A gift to a customer’s family member is generally an indirect gift to the customer, unless you have an independent business connection with that family member.
- Delivery costs usually do not count. Incidental costs such as packaging, insuring and mailing are generally left out of the $25 test, as long as they do not add substantial value.
- Logo items under $4 are exempt. An item costing $4 or less with your name permanently imprinted, one of many identical items you hand out widely, is not a gift for the $25 limit.
Worked example. You send a former client the Version B card ($25) in March and a $40 holiday basket in December. Gifts to that person for the year: $25 + $40 = $65. Deductible: $25. The extra $40 buys goodwill, not a deduction.
The nuance tax people will catch: 274(b) defines a “gift” as an item excludable from the recipient’s income under section 102. A card that is conditioned on booking and attending a review is arguably payment for the meeting rather than a gift, which changes how you treat and report it. The same point applies to paid referral rewards in our referral thank-you email templates for accounting firms. Have your own tax team settle the treatment of Version A before you launch it.
Attest clients: the AICPA gift rule
Under AICPA Code 1.285.010.04 (the Code is updated for all official releases through September 2026), offering a gift or entertainment to an attest client during the engagement period that “is not reasonable in the circumstances” impairs independence, and safeguards cannot fix it. Paragraph .05 lists the factors: the nature of the gift, the occasion, its cost or value, and the nature, frequency and value of other gifts and entertainment. Paragraph .01 widens “attest client” to include an individual in a key position with the client, or an owner whose interest gives significant influence. So the CFO of your audit client is out of the gift card segment too. Send attest clients the no-incentive version below.
IRC 7216: when your client list needs a signed consent
Your client list is tax return information. Treas. Reg. 301.7216-1 defines it to include “a taxpayer’s name, address, or identifying number” furnished in connection with preparing a return. Two rules then decide what a re-engagement email may do with it:
- The client-list exception. 301.7216-2(n) lets you keep a separate list containing solely names, mailing addresses, email addresses, phone numbers, entity classification and the return form number (for example, Form 1040). You may use it to contact those taxpayers to provide tax information, general business or economic information for educational purposes, or to solicit additional tax return preparation services. “The list may not be used to solicit any service or product other than tax return preparation services.” The examples in (n)(2) allow filtering by zip code and form number.
- Everything else needs consent first. Under 301.7216-3, other uses need written consent, signed and dated before the use. The consent must describe the particular use, and it lasts one year from signing if no duration is stated. You cannot make return preparation conditional on it. For Form 1040 filers, Rev. Proc. 2013-14 requires a separate written document (it can be attached to the engagement letter), in at least 12-point type on paper, with mandatory wording that begins “Federal law requires this consent form be provided to you.”
In practice: “Come back to us for your 2026 return” sent to the (n) list fits the exception. A gift card offer for a paid planning engagement, or a segment built from income, Schedule C or retirement account data, falls outside it on the conservative reading, so get the consent first. The full consent wording, in the required order, is in our tax client questionnaire template. Prospects who never gave you return information are not on a 7216 list. A prospect who sent a prior-year return for a quote is a judgment call; treat that information as covered.
Circular 230: claims, solicitations and record keeping
If your firm practices before the IRS, 31 CFR 10.30 shapes four parts of the email:
- No misleading claims. 10.30(a)(1) bars communications containing “a false, fraudulent, or coercive statement or claim; or a misleading or deceptive statement or claim.” So “we will find you $4,000” is out. Offer the review, not a result.
- Say why they got it. Under 10.30(a)(2), a lawful uninvited solicitation must “clearly identify the solicitation as such and, if applicable, identify the source of the information used in choosing the recipient.” The footer line “You are receiving it because…” does that job.
- Stop when told. Under 10.30(c), a practitioner “may not persist in attempting to contact a prospective client” who has said they do not want to be solicited. A sunset email that honors the answer keeps you on the right side of this.
- Keep a copy. 10.30(b) lists “fee charged for an initial consultation” as fee information, so a free 20-minute review arguably counts. When a direct mail or email communication states fee information, 10.30(c) requires you to keep a copy of the actual communication and the list of recipients for at least 36 months. Export both from your email tool after every send.
CAN-SPAM: the footer every version needs
The FTC’s CAN-SPAM compliance guide uses almost exactly this case as its example: email to former customers is covered, and there is no exception for business-to-business email. The requirements:
- Honest From, To and Reply-To lines, and a subject line that matches the content.
- A clear and conspicuous disclosure that the message is an advertisement.
- Your valid physical postal address: a street address, a registered PO box or a registered private mailbox.
- An opt-out that keeps working for at least 30 days after you send, honored within 10 business days. You cannot charge a fee, ask for more than an email address, or require more than a reply or a visit to a single web page.
- Penalties of up to $53,088 for each email in violation.
Gift card rules: what the federal law covers
The CFPB’s gift card rule, Regulation E section 1005.20, governs gift certificates, store gift cards and general-use prepaid cards:
- Five-year funds. The underlying funds cannot expire sooner than five years after the card was issued or last loaded (or the card’s own expiration date, if later).
- Dormancy fees. A dormancy, inactivity or service fee is allowed only after a full year with no activity, no more than one per calendar month, and only if it is disclosed on the card.
- Promotional cards. A “loyalty, award, or promotional gift card” is excluded only if it carries specific disclosures: a statement on the front that it is promotional, the expiration date of the funds on the front, the amount of any fees, and a toll-free number for fee information.
These duties sit with the issuer. If you buy a retailer’s card or send cards through a rewards platform, the issuer handles them. Tremendous’s pricing page, for example, lists platform access and bulk sending at $0, gift cards sent at face value, free funding from a bank account and a 3% fee for funding by credit card, with recipients choosing from more than 2,300 options. If you issue your own “$25 off your planning fee” certificate instead, call it a fee credit with an end date, and check your state’s gift certificate law before printing anything that looks like a card. This page covers federal rules only.
California firms: check before you send Version A
California Business and Professions Code 5061 says a licensee shall not “pay a fee or commission to obtain a client,” and defines “fee” to include “a commission, rebate, preference, discount, or other consideration, whether in the form of money or otherwise.” Whether a $25 card to a prospect for a review counts is a question for the California Board of Accountancy. Until you have an answer, use the no-incentive version.
A 3-email re-engagement sequence for lapsed tax clients
Run it on day 0, day 7 and day 14, the spacing our win-back campaign guide uses for service firms. Email 1 carries no offer, so you learn who comes back without paying for it. Each email stops for anyone who books, replies or unsubscribes. My preference is to send in May or June, after the season, or from September to early December when year-end planning has a real deadline. Never send in the two weeks before April 15.
| # | Send | Subject | Offer | Stops when |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Day 0 | One 2026 change that may touch your return | None | Booked, replied or unsubscribed |
| 2 | Day 7 | A $25 thank-you for 20 minutes of your time | Version A card (or no incentive for attest clients and California firms) | Booked, replied or unsubscribed |
| 3 | Day 14 | Should we close your file? | None (sunset) | Any answer; then suppress non-responders |
Email 1 body:
Hi [First name],
One thing changed since we last worked together: [specific 2026 rule change, deadline or new service, with the IRS source]. For someone who [their situation in one phrase, for example “sold a rental in 2025”], that can mean [one concrete consequence, stated without a dollar promise].
If you want to know whether it applies to you, reply with a quick yes and I will send two times that work, or book here: [booking link].
[Your name]
Email 2: Version A above, with one added opening line: “Following up on my note last week.”
Email 3: the sunset email below.
Re-engagement email for cold prospects who never signed
Prospects who downloaded a guide or booked a call and went quiet need a shorter run: two emails, not three, and a stop the moment they say no. Where these leads come from and what each source costs is in our breakdown of lead generation for tax planning firms. For people who never opted in at all, start with first-touch outreach from our cold email templates for tax firms instead.
Subject: Still planning for [goal they gave, for example “the business sale”]?
Hi [First name],
You downloaded our [2026 Year-End Tax Checklist] on [date] and mentioned [goal from the form]. If that is still on the calendar, the months before [deadline] are when planning options are widest.
I can do a 20-minute review call at no charge, and we will send a $25 e-gift card after the call as a thank-you. Book by [date]: [link].
If the timing is wrong, reply “later” and I will check back in [month]. Reply “stop” and you will not hear from me again.
[Your name], [Firm name]
Footer for prospects: “This email is an advertisement from [Firm name], [postal address]. You are receiving it because you requested [resource] from our website on [date]. Unsubscribe with one click: [link].”
Re-engagement email with no incentive
Use this for attest clients, for California firms waiting on the Board, and for any segment where a card would feel odd. It borrows the reason-coded reply from B2B win-back: the answer tells you what to do next.
Subject: Are we still your tax contact?
Hi [First name],
It has been a while since we worked on your [year] return, and I would rather ask than assume. Could you reply with one number?
1: Yes, keep me posted on changes that affect me.
2: I would like a short review before [December 31].
3: I have moved on. Please take me off your list.Whatever the answer, thank you for trusting us with your return.
[Your name]
Then honor it: 1 goes to your quarterly update segment, 2 gets a booking link within one business day, 3 is unsubscribed the same day.
The sunset email, and when to stop mailing
Subject: Should we close your file?
Hi [First name],
I have written twice and not heard back, which usually means the timing is wrong. That is completely fine.
So we do not clutter your inbox, this is the last marketing email you will get from us unless you click below.
[Button: Keep me on the list]
[Button: Book a review]If we do not hear from you, we will stop sending updates on [date]. Your records stay with us as required, and you can reach us any time at [phone].
[Your name]
After the date, move everyone who did not click, reply or book to a suppressed segment. Keeping dead addresses on the list is how spam complaints build up, and the two largest mailbox providers publish hard limits:
| Rule | Gmail | Yahoo | What it means for re-engagement |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who it applies to | Senders of 5,000 or more messages a day to Gmail accounts, a status that never expires once reached; enforcement on non-compliant traffic ramped up from November 2025 (Google sender FAQ) | Bulk sender rules on top of rules for all senders (Yahoo sender best practices) | One big send to an old list can make you a bulk sender for good |
| Spam rate | Below 0.3% in Postmaster Tools; Google’s target is below 0.10% (Google sender guidelines) | Below 0.3% | Old segments produce the complaints, so keep them short |
| Unsubscribe | One-click unsubscribe for marketing and subscribed messages plus a visible link in the body; Google recommends honoring requests within 48 hours | One-click via the List-Unsubscribe header (RFC 8058 POST highly recommended); honor within 2 days | An unsubscribe after email 1 must stop emails 2 and 3 |
| Authentication | SPF and DKIM, DMARC at p=none or stricter, From domain aligned | SPF and DKIM for bulk senders, DMARC at least p=none | Set up once on your sending domain |
The full pass/fail version of this check, plus the DNS steps, is in our guide to email marketing for CPA firms.
Build the dormant segment before you write a word
- Start from your practice management system, not opens. Pull contacts with no return filed, no invoice and no reply in 12 or more months. Keep only the (n) list fields: name, email, mailing address, phone, entity type, form number.
- Remove three groups: attest clients and their officers, anyone who unsubscribed or said no, and anyone with an open engagement.
- Split by form number and zip code if the email depends on it. The 7216-2(n)(2) examples allow both. Splits based on income or schedules need a signed consent.
- In Mailchimp, go to Audience, then Segments. The pre-built “Disengaged Subscribers” segment covers subscribed contacts who “haven’t opened all of your last five emails,” and Mailchimp says engagement segments are available on all accounts. Intersect it with your 12-month list rather than using it alone.
- Hold out 10% at random. They get nothing, so you can see how many lapsed clients would have come back anyway.
KPIs for a tax firm re-engagement campaign
| KPI | Formula | Reference line |
|---|---|---|
| Spam complaint rate | Complaints / delivered, per send | Below 0.10%, never 0.3% (Google) |
| Unsubscribe rate | Unsubscribes / delivered | 0.16% median for business and finance (MailerLite, 3.6M+ campaigns, Dec 2024 to Nov 2025); expect higher on an old list |
| Click rate | Unique clicks / delivered | 2.37% median for business and finance (MailerLite). Klaviyo puts win-back emails at 2.8% average, 5.8% top 10% (Klaviyo, October 2, 2026), but that is ecommerce data |
| Reply rate | Replies / delivered | Your own baseline; the no-incentive version should beat the others here |
| Booked review rate | Reviews booked / delivered | Compare Version A against email 1 to price the card |
| Show rate | Reviews held / booked | Cards go out only for held calls |
| Reactivation rate | Signed engagements / delivered, minus the holdout rate | The number that pays for the campaign |
| Cost per reactivated client | (Cards + platform fees) / signed engagements | Set against first-year fees |
Worked example (assumptions, replace with yours). You have 500 lapsed clients: 450 get the sequence and 50 are held out. Email 2 books 15 reviews, 12 calls happen, and 4 clients sign. Cards: 12 x $25 = $300. Funded by bank transfer through a platform that lists $0 platform and sending fees, that is the whole cash cost. Cost per reactivated client: $300 / 4 = $75. Now check the holdout. If 0 of the 50 come back on their own, all 4 signings are incremental. If 1 of 50 does (2.0%), you would expect about 9 of the 450 to return without any email, so 4 signings means the sequence added nothing you can measure. With lists this small, read the holdout across two or three campaigns before you decide.
Re-engagement is one of the calendar-tied plays in our list of tax planning firm marketing ideas, and it works best when replies land on a booking page someone actually watches. If you want a second opinion on the segment rules, the offer or the holdout design before the first send, you can book a consultation.
Frequently asked questions
What should a re-engagement gift card email template include?
A personal opening that names the last work you did together, one real reason to talk now, a single offer such as a $25 e-gift card for a 20-minute review, a booking deadline, short offer terms, and a footer with an ad disclosure, your postal address, why they received it and a one-click unsubscribe. Keep it under 150 words and give one link.
How much can a tax firm deduct for a gift card sent to a client?
Under IRC 274(b), business gifts are deductible only up to $25 per recipient per tax year. IRS Publication 463 treats a partnership and its partners as one giver and spouses as one recipient. A card given only after someone books and attends a review may not be a gift at all, because 274(b) relies on the section 102 definition, so have your tax team settle the treatment.
Can a CPA firm send a gift card to an audit client to re-engage them?
Be careful. AICPA Code 1.285.010.04 says offering a gift or entertainment to an attest client that is not reasonable in the circumstances impairs independence, and safeguards cannot fix it. The rule also covers individuals in key positions at the client. The safe default is to leave attest clients out of gift card sends and use a no-incentive check-in email.
Do I need client consent to send re-engagement emails to former tax clients?
Not for every email. Treas. Reg. 301.7216-2(n) lets you use a list of names, contact details, entity type and form number to share tax information or solicit more tax return preparation. Soliciting any other service, such as a paid planning engagement, or targeting by income or schedules needs a signed 7216 consent before you use the information.
How many emails should a re-engagement sequence have?
Three for lapsed clients: day 0 with no offer, day 7 with the incentive, and day 14 as a sunset email that asks whether to close the file. Use two for prospects who never signed. Stop each contact the moment they book, reply or unsubscribe, and suppress anyone who ignores the sunset email after the stated date.
What are the Gmail and Yahoo rules for re-engagement emails?
Both require a spam rate below 0.3%, and Google's target is below 0.10%. Marketing emails need one-click unsubscribe through the List-Unsubscribe header plus a visible link. Yahoo requires unsubscribes to be honored within 2 days and Google recommends 48 hours. Senders of 5,000 or more messages a day to Gmail accounts become bulk senders permanently.
Do gift cards used in marketing emails expire?
Under Regulation E section 1005.20, funds on gift certificates, store gift cards and general-use prepaid cards cannot expire sooner than five years after issue or last load, and dormancy fees are allowed only after a year of inactivity. These duties sit with the card issuer. Promotional cards are excluded only when they carry the required disclosures, including the expiration date on the front.
More marketing guides for tax planning firms
About the author
Christoph Olivier Christoph Olivier is the founder of CO Consulting and a fractional CMO who has managed millions of dollars in ad spend and built a combined audience of over a million followers across social platforms.