
Client retention for accounting firms comes down to two numbers you can measure every year: the share of last year’s clients still with you, and the share of last year’s fees they still pay. If you are buying or selling a practice, retention is also a deal term. Most sale agreements either fix the price at closing or adjust it after a look-back period based on what the transferred clients actually pay, so whoever carries that risk should control the plan to keep them.
This page gives you both halves: how practice sales handle client retention (with a worked earnout example, the AICPA consent rule and a transition letter you can copy), then the playbook for an existing firm: the formulas, a fee-weighted NPS, a value segmentation table, a 2027 touchpoint calendar built on the actual filing deadlines, price-increase handling and an exit interview template.
How many clients stay after an accounting practice acquisition?
There is no reliable published average, and you should be wary of anyone who quotes one as a forecast. The spread in real deals is wide. In Accounting Today’s 2017 report on M&A retention, Jeff Gentner, an EA in Amherst, N.Y., said that across the small tax practices he bought, “each time 5 percent to 85 percent of the clients accepted the change.” He priced those deals on the first year’s gross income, so the seller had a reason to help.
What the brokers agree on is who controls the outcome. Todd Steinberg, writing in CPA Practice Advisor (June 8, 2017), put it bluntly: “In reality, the buyer has almost all of the control over client retention!” An Accounting Practice Sales article published by the Michigan Association of CPAs on November 11, 2024 makes the same case: “The seller helps with client retention but the bulk of the responsibility, by far, is with the buyer.” Brannon Poe of Poe Group Advisors goes further in 5 Reasons to Avoid an Earnout (page last modified August 20, 2026): he argues that “pure earnouts place the risk on the wrong party,” that cash buyers tend to lose fewer clients than earnout buyers, and that his firm aims for sellers to get 70% to 100% cash at close.
So the honest answer to “how many clients will I keep” is: it depends on what the buyer does in the first year, and the contract decides who pays for the clients who leave.
The four ways a sale price handles client retention
Accounting Practice Sales laid out the structures in “Show Me the Money” in Nebraska CPA Magazine (December 16, 2025). Two put retention risk on the seller, two put it on the buyer.
| Structure | How retention changes the price | Who carries the risk | Published terms |
|---|---|---|---|
| Collection pricing | Seller is paid a share of what the clients actually pay over several years | Seller | Traditional example: 20% of the estimated price down, then 20% of collections a year for the first four years |
| Look-back pricing | Price is set, then adjusted after a look-back period on actual collections or billings; seller may get all cash at close and refund part later | Seller | Dollar-for-dollar adjustment is common; alternatives are 50 cents per dollar, adjusting only after a 10% change, or caps. In a 12-month look-back “the seller guarantees each client will show up at least once” |
| Cash pricing | None: 100% of the price paid at closing | Buyer | Buyer uses own funds or a lender; third-party loans are “often extended over 10 years” |
| Fixed seller-financed | None: price set before closing, seller carries a note | Buyer | Price stays “static throughout the life of the loan”; seller financing typically runs three to five years |
Poe adds a warning that applies to the first two rows. In his CPA firm purchase agreement guide (last modified October 29, 2026), he cites SRS Acquiom data that about two-thirds of retention-based deals in general business sales lead to conflicts over escrowed funds. If you do accept a contingency, his advice is to “treat any contingent payments as a bonus, not as money they’re counting on.”
Worked earnout example: what a 12% shortfall does under each structure
Every number below is an assumption chosen to make the math visible. None is market data.
- Seller’s trailing 12-month collections from the clients being sold: $500,000.
- Agreed headline price: $500,000 (1.0x collections, assumed for round numbers).
- Year-one collections from those same clients under the buyer: $440,000, a 12% shortfall of $60,000.
- For collection pricing, assumed collections in years two to four: $430,000, $420,000 and $410,000.
- For the cash deal, assumed price: $475,000, a 5% concession for removing the contingency.
| Structure | Math | Seller receives | Buyer pays per $1 of year-one retained collections |
|---|---|---|---|
| Look-back, dollar for dollar | $500,000 minus $60,000 | $440,000 | $440,000 ÷ $440,000 = 1.00 |
| Look-back, 50 cents per dollar | $500,000 minus ($60,000 × 0.5) | $470,000 | $470,000 ÷ $440,000 = 1.07 |
| Look-back, 10% threshold (only the excess adjusted) | Shortfall 12%, excess 2% = $10,000; $500,000 minus $10,000 | $490,000 | $490,000 ÷ $440,000 = 1.11 |
| Collection pricing, 20% down + 20% of collections for 4 years | $100,000 + 20% × ($440,000 + $430,000 + $420,000 + $410,000) = $100,000 + $340,000 | $440,000, spread over four years | $440,000 ÷ $440,000 = 1.00 |
| Fixed cash at close | No adjustment | $475,000 at closing | $475,000 ÷ $440,000 = 1.08 |
Three things to take from the table. First, the threshold wording matters: “adjust only after a 10% change” can mean the whole shortfall is adjusted once it passes 10% (here, $60,000) or only the part above 10% ($10,000). That is a $50,000 difference, so write it out with an example in the agreement. Second, the seller’s total under collection pricing equals the dollar-for-dollar look-back here, but the seller waits four years and carries four years of attrition. Third, on these assumptions the seller gives up $35,000 of headline price ($500,000 versus $475,000) in the cash deal and still ends up $35,000 ahead of the dollar-for-dollar outcome ($475,000 versus $440,000).
To measure the look-back, use one ratio and agree on it before closing: retained collections ratio = collections received in the look-back period from transferred clients ÷ base-period collections from the same clients. Here, $440,000 ÷ $500,000 = 88%. Also agree how fee increases, new services sold to transferred clients and referrals from them are counted. A buyer who raises fees 10% can show flat collections while losing clients, so decide in writing whether the look-back counts clients, fees at the seller’s rates, or actual collections.
The AICPA consent letter and its 90-day clock
Before any files move, the seller must ask clients for consent. Under AICPA ET 1.400.205, effective June 30, 2017, as summarized by April Sherman in the Journal of Accountancy (August 2, 2017), the selling firm sends a written request telling clients that “if the clients do not respond within 90 days, the clients’ consent will be presumed.” Joshua Hayes of Eide Bailly, writing for the Alabama Society of CPAs (December 17, 2025), lists what the request must do: explain the nature of the transaction, identify the acquiring firm, give a 90-day window, and say consent is presumed without a response. He also notes the acquiring firm must not access or use the files until written consent arrives or the 90 days pass. Check your state board’s rules as well.
Do the date math before you set a closing date. A letter dated Monday, November 2, 2026 reaches day 90 on Sunday, January 31, 2027. A letter dated Tuesday, December 1, 2026 reaches day 90 on Monday, March 1, 2027, two weeks before the March 15 partnership and S corporation deadline. Include a one-click or signed “yes, transfer my file” reply so most consents arrive long before day 90.
Client transition letter template (seller and buyer, after closing)
This letter combines the consent request with the reassurance clients need. Replace everything in brackets, and have your attorney check it against the deal’s legal structure: Harry Olson’s Journal of Accountancy article (September 1, 2016) recommends that review before any sale or merger announcement, and Poe warns that “framing a sale as a merger or new partnership when it isn’t one tends to backfire.”
Subject: [Seller firm] is joining [Buyer firm]: what changes for you, and what does not
Dear [Client first name],
After [number] years of working with you, I have decided to [retire / reduce my practice] on [date]. I spent [time period] looking for a firm I would trust with your work, and I chose [Buyer name] of [Buyer firm] because [one specific reason: e.g., they work with many [industry] businesses / they file on the same schedule we do / they kept a predecessor’s staff for years].
What stays the same: [Staff member name] will keep preparing your work. Our office at [address] stays open through [date, at least the end of the 2027 filing season]. Your fees for [service] will stay at [current fee / current fee plus a stated adjustment] for the [2026] return. Your portal login does not change.
What I will do: I will work alongside [Buyer name] through [date] and will introduce you personally at [meeting type] in [month].
Your files and your consent: [Seller firm] is [selling its practice to / combining with] [Buyer firm, full legal name, address, phone]. With your permission, we will transfer your client files to [Buyer firm]. If you agree, reply “yes” or sign below. If you would prefer that we do not transfer your files, tell us in writing by [date 90 days from this letter] at [email/address]. If we do not hear from you within 90 days, your consent will be presumed. You remain free to choose any accountant, and we will return your records if you ask.
[Buyer name] will call you within [one week] to set up a short meeting. You can reach [him/her] directly at [mobile number].
Thank you for trusting me with your work.
[Seller name] and [Buyer name]
The buyer’s first 90 days: what the sources say keeps clients
- Contact everyone fast. Edward Mendlowitz of WithumSmith+Brown, in Accounting Today (September 19, 2022), aims for three meetings in the first six weeks: one immediately, one a week or two later, and one a couple of weeks after that. Call small tax clients too, since they may refer larger work.
- Tell them you have their files. Mendlowitz: “Assuring the clients you have access and possession of their prior work will certainly be a calming influence.”
- Change as little as possible through the first busy season. Olson’s JofA list: keep the office open at least through the first busy season, keep billing terms close to the seller’s (his example is 30-day payment versus switching to a 50% retainer), and do not file extensions the former owner would not have filed.
- Set the fee expectation in writing. Mendlowitz’s example is a 5% inflation increase, so a $700 return becomes $735, with pricing for any added services agreed up front.
- Check whether the seller undercharged. Laurie Ziegler of Sass Accounting, quoted in the Accounting Today M&A piece, warns that clients may leave when they see the buyer’s higher rates. Price that gap into the deal, not into the first invoice.
- Keep the seller visible. Jeffrey Schneider, EA, told Accounting Today that having the owner in place, especially near tax season, is “invaluable.”
Client retention for accounting firms: the formulas, with worked math
These are the same definitions used in our customer retention and churn statistics, so your numbers line up with the benchmarks there. Count clients as billing relationships (one household or one business group), and measure from one filing season to the next.
| Metric | Formula | Worked example (illustrative firm) |
|---|---|---|
| Client retention rate (Zendesk) | ((E minus N) ÷ S) × 100, where E = clients at the end of the period, N = clients added during it, S = clients at the start | 400 clients on January 1, 2026, 52 added, 412 on December 31: (412 minus 52) ÷ 400 = 90% |
| Client churn rate (Zendesk) | (Churned clients ÷ original number of clients) × 100 | 40 of the 400 left: 40 ÷ 400 = 10% |
| Net fee retention (ChartMogul’s NRR, using annual fees instead of MRR) | (Starting fees + expansion + reactivation minus contraction minus churned fees) ÷ starting fees | ($900,000 + $63,000 + $0 minus $18,000 minus $72,000) ÷ $900,000 = 97.0% |
| Gross fee retention | (Starting fees minus contraction minus churned fees) ÷ starting fees; cannot exceed 100% | ($900,000 minus $18,000 minus $72,000) ÷ $900,000 = 90.0% |
| Average client lifetime | 1 ÷ churn rate | 1 ÷ 0.10 = 10 years |
Read the four together. In the example, 90% of clients stayed and 90% of the starting fees were kept, but upsells pulled net fee retention to 97%. A firm can post the same 90% client retention while losing its two largest business clients, which shows up only in gross fee retention. For an outside reference point, CustomerGauge’s B2B table (dated June 13, 2026) lists professional services at a 73% median retention rate. It discloses no sample size, survey year or measurement period, so treat it as directional and use your own prior year as the real benchmark.
NPS for a CPA firm, weighted by the fees each client pays
Ask Bain’s exact question so your score is comparable: “How likely are you to recommend us to a friend or colleague?” on a 0 to 10 scale. Bain’s formula is the percentage of promoters (9 or 10) minus the percentage of detractors (0 to 6). For an accounting firm, run the weighted version alongside it, using each client’s annual fees as the weight, the method in our net promoter score guide and in QuestionPro’s revenue-weighted NPS walkthrough: sum the fees behind promoters and behind detractors, divide each by total fees, and subtract.
| Client (illustrative) | Annual fees | Score | Group |
|---|---|---|---|
| A: W-2 household | $1,200 | 10 | Promoter |
| B: retiree | $900 | 9 | Promoter |
| C: rental owner | $2,400 | 9 | Promoter |
| D: single filer | $650 | 10 | Promoter |
| E: S corp, payroll + return | $9,600 | 6 | Detractor |
| F: sole proprietor | $3,500 | 8 | Passive |
| G: household with K-1s | $1,800 | 9 | Promoter |
| H: partnership | $7,500 | 7 | Passive |
| I: multi-entity owner, monthly accounting | $14,400 | 5 | Detractor |
| J: small business return | $1,100 | 3 | Detractor |
- Standard NPS: 5 promoters, 2 passives, 3 detractors out of 10 = 50% minus 30% = +20.
- Fee-weighted NPS: total fees $43,050. Promoter fees $6,950 = 16.1%. Detractor fees $25,100 = 58.3%. 16.1 minus 58.3 = minus 42.2.
The headline +20 hides that more than half the fees sit with unhappy clients, including the two monthly accounts. That gap is the retention risk list. The NPS guide’s recommendation for a few hundred clients: the relationship partner calls every detractor within 2 business days, by phone, and agrees one fix with a date. With around 60 clients, read the comments and track direction rather than reporting the score to the point. If you want the full questionnaire, start from our client satisfaction survey template for accountants.
Segment clients by value before you decide who gets what
Retention effort is not free, so spend it where the fees and the referrals are. The cut-offs below are my starting point, not an industry standard. Sort clients by annual fees, then adjust for effort and fit.
| Tier | How to define it | Retention touch | Owner | Fee approach |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A: anchor | Clients who together make up the first 50% of fees when sorted largest first; usually monthly or multi-entity | Quarterly planning meeting, plus a call before every deadline that affects them | Partner | Annual increase tied to scope; review in a meeting, not a letter |
| B: core | The next 30% of fees; returns plus one other service | Two planned touches between seasons (mid-year and Q4 planning) | Manager | Standard annual increase by letter |
| C: standard | The remaining clients at or above your minimum fee | Deadline reminders and one value email a quarter | Staff, automated | Standard increase; move to packages |
| D: below floor | Below your minimum fee, or effort hours out of line with fees | Deadline reminders only | Admin | Reprice to the floor or release politely |
Two flags override the tier. A tier B or C client who refers others behaves like a tier A relationship, so give them the partner call. And any client who scored 0 to 6 on the NPS question, paid late twice, or went silent on two document requests moves to the at-risk list, whatever their tier.
Client engagement for accounting firms: a 2027 touchpoint calendar
The easiest retention gain for most small firms is to talk to clients before a deadline instead of only when you need documents. The dates below come from the statutes and IRS rules: estimated payments are due April 15, June 15, September 15 and January 15 under 26 U.S.C. 6654(c)(2); W-2s and nonemployee compensation returns are due January 31 under 26 U.S.C. 6071(c); and IRS Publication 509 (2026) sets Form 1065 and 1120-S at the 15th day of the 3rd month, Form 1040 and Form 1120 at the 15th day of the 4th month, with 6-month extensions. When a date falls on a weekend or legal holiday, 26 U.S.C. 7503 moves it to the next business day, which is why the January 31, 2027 date (a Sunday) becomes Monday, February 1. Publication 509 for 2027 was not out when this was written, so recheck it in January, and check IRS disaster relief notices, which postpone deadlines for affected areas.
| 2027 deadline | What is due (calendar-year filers) | Touchpoint and when to send it | Tiers |
|---|---|---|---|
| Friday, January 15 | 4th installment of 2026 estimated tax | Monday, January 4: estimate check-in for anyone with 2026 income changes | A, B |
| Monday, February 1 | Forms W-2 and 1099-NEC (January 31 falls on a Sunday) | Early January: payroll and contractor list confirmation | A, B business clients |
| Monday, March 15 | Form 1065 and Form 1120-S returns or extensions | Mid-February: K-1 timing note to partners and shareholders, plus extension decision | A, B entities |
| Thursday, April 15 | Form 1040 and Form 1120, Form 4868 extensions, 1st 2027 estimated installment | Late March: “where your return stands” status note; after filing: a 2027 planning invitation | All |
| Tuesday, June 15 | 2nd 2027 estimated installment | Early June: mid-year check-in (the touch most firms skip) | A, B |
| Wednesday, September 15 | 3rd 2027 estimated installment; extended Form 1065 and 1120-S | Late August: extended-return status note and Q3 estimate reminder | A, B, C with extensions |
| Friday, October 15 | Extended Form 1040 and Form 1120 | Late September: final status note; after filing: thank-you and Q4 planning offer | All extended |
| November and December | No federal deadline; year-end planning window | Q4 planning meeting, engagement letters and any fee change for 2028 | A in person, B by call, C by email |
Raise fees without losing the clients you want to keep
A fee increase is the most common moment a quiet client starts shopping, so run the math before the letters go out. The break-even rule from our price increase letter templates for accountants: if you raise a segment’s fees by p, you can lose up to p ÷ (1 + p) of that segment’s revenue and still collect the same total. A 10% increase breaks even at 9.1% of revenue lost; a 25% increase at 20%. Apply it by tier: protect tier A with small, scope-based increases, and take the larger increases in tier D, where losing clients also frees hours. After an acquisition, hold the seller’s fees through the first season unless the deal priced in the gap, for the reasons Ziegler and Olson give above.
Client exit interview template for accounting firms
When a client leaves, you have one chance to learn why. In a CPA Practice Advisor report on Sam’s List survey data (April 30, 2026), 52.7% of business owners said their accountant was not meeting their needs and 34.8% said they were actively looking to replace their accountant. The article does not state the sample size, so treat those as a signal, not a benchmark. Your own exit interviews are the better data. Return records promptly whatever the reason: AICPA ET 1.400.200 governs returning client records, and a slow handover is the last impression the client gets.
Subject: 10 minutes to help us do better?
Hi [First name], thank you for letting us know you are moving your [service] to another firm. Your records will be ready by [date, within a few business days]. Before you go, would you give me 10 minutes by phone this week? I am not calling to change your mind. I want to know what we should fix. [Two time options] or reply here if email is easier.
[Name], [Title]
Ask these in order, and type the answers into the client record the same day:
- What was the main reason you decided to move? (Let them answer before offering options.)
- When did you first start thinking about it, and what happened then?
- Was there a specific moment we missed: a deadline, a slow reply, a surprise invoice, a mistake?
- What does the new firm offer that we did not, or did not tell you we offered?
- How did our fees compare with the value you felt you were getting?
- Who did you deal with most here, and how was that relationship?
- On a scale of 0 to 10, how likely are you to recommend us to a friend or colleague?
- If you could change one thing about how we work, what would it be?
- Would you be open to hearing from us next year if we fix that?
Code each exit with one primary reason so you can count them at year-end: price, responsiveness, error or missed deadline, service gap (they needed advisory, payroll or a specialty you did not offer), relationship (their contact left), life event (moved, sold the business, died), or firm-initiated (you released them). The first five are the ones a retention plan can change. If three or more exits in a year share a reason, that is a process fix for the managing partner, not a coaching note for one staff member.
Where retention feeds new clients
Retained clients are also your referral base, which is why the referral section of how CPA and accounting firms get clients starts with client referrals. When a retained client does send someone, thank them inside the AICPA and state rules using one of these referral thank-you email templates for accountants. Then work through this list:
- Calculate last season’s client retention, net fee retention and gross fee retention with the formulas above.
- Tier every client by annual fees and flag the at-risk list.
- Put the 2027 touchpoints in your practice management calendar now, before the January rush.
- Send the NPS question to all clients after the April 15 deadline passes, and call every detractor within 2 business days.
- If you are buying or selling a practice, agree on the retained collections ratio, the threshold wording and the consent letter date before you sign.
If you want a second set of eyes on the segmentation or the transition plan, you can book a consultation.
Frequently asked questions
How many clients stay after an accounting practice acquisition?
There is no reliable published average. Real deals vary widely: one EA quoted by Accounting Today in 2017 said 5% to 85% of clients accepted the change across his purchases. Brokers including Accounting Practice Sales and Poe Group Advisors say the buyer controls most of the outcome through service, pricing and fast personal contact, so measure retained collections rather than relying on a forecast.
How is client retention handled in a CPA practice sale?
Through the price structure. Collection pricing pays the seller a share of what clients pay over several years, and look-back pricing adjusts a set price after a period such as 12 months, often dollar for dollar. Cash and fixed seller-financed deals do not adjust for retention, so the buyer carries that risk. Agree the measurement ratio and threshold wording in writing before closing.
What notice must a seller give clients in a CPA practice merger or sale?
Under AICPA ET 1.400.205, the seller sends each client a written request for consent to transfer files that explains the transaction, names the acquiring firm and states that consent is presumed if the client does not respond within 90 days. The buyer should not use the files until consent arrives or the 90 days pass. Check state board rules too.
How do you calculate client retention for an accounting firm?
Use ((E minus N) divided by S) times 100, where E is clients at the end of the period, N is clients added during it and S is clients at the start. Example: 400 clients on January 1, 52 added, 412 on December 31 gives (412 minus 52) divided by 400, or 90%. Track net and gross fee retention alongside it so losing a large client shows up.
What is the easiest way for an accounting firm owner to improve client retention?
Contact clients before deadlines instead of only when you need documents or send a bill. Put a short check-in two to three weeks ahead of the 2027 estimated tax dates and return deadlines for your top clients, send the NPS question after April 15, and have the relationship partner call every client who scores 0 to 6 within two business days.
What does client engagement mean for an accounting firm?
It means planned, useful contact between engagements: a mid-year check-in, a K-1 timing note before March 15, an extension status update before September 15 or October 15, and a year-end planning meeting. Tie each touch to a real deadline and a client tier so your partners spend time on the clients who make up most of your fees.
More marketing guides for cpa
- Marketing Channels for CPA and Accounting Firms: How to Build the Mix
- Video Marketing for CPA and Accounting Firms
- Podcast Strategy for CPA and Accounting Firms
- Client Onboarding for CPA and Accounting Firms: Turning It Into a Referral Asset
- Marketing Calendar for CPA and Accounting Firms
- Marketing Tech Stack for CPA and Accounting Firms
- Marketing for CPA & Accounting Firms
About the author
Christoph Olivier Christoph Olivier is the founder of CO Consulting and a fractional CMO who has managed millions of dollars in ad spend and built a combined audience of over a million followers across social platforms.